• Home
  • Textbooks
  • Cengage Advantage Books: Understanding Arguments: An Introduction to Informal Logic
  • Causal Reasoning

Cengage Advantage Books: Understanding Arguments: An Introduction to Informal Logic

Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, Robert J. Fogelin

Chapter 10

Causal Reasoning - all with Video Answers

Educators


Chapter Questions

Problem 1

Which of the following claims are true? Which are false?
1. Being a car is a sufficient condition for being a vehicle.
2. Being a car is a necessary condition for being a vehicle.
3. Being a vehicle is a sufficient condition for being a car.
4. Being a vehicle is a necessary condition for being a car.
5. Being an integer is a sufficient condition for being an even number.
6. Being an integer is a necessary condition for being an even number.
7. Being an integer is a sufficient condition for being either an even number or an odd number.
8. Being an integer is a necessary condition for being either an even number or an odd number.
9. Not being an integer is a sufficient condition for not being an odd number.
10. Not being an integer is a sufficient condition for not being an even number.
11. Being both an integer and divisible by 2 without remainder is a sufficient condition for being an even number.
12. Being both an integer and divisible by 2 without remainder is a necessary condition for being an even number.
13. Being an integer divisible by 2 without remainder is a necessary condition for being an even number.
14. Driving seventy-five miles per hour (for fun) is a sufficient condition for violating a legal speed limit of sixty-five miles per hour.
15. Driving seventy-five miles per hour (for fun) is a necessary condition for violating a legal speed limit of sixty-five miles per hour.
16. Cutting off Joe's head is a sufficient condition for killing him.
17. Cutting off Joe's head is a necessary condition for killing him.
18. Cutting off Joe's head and then holding his head under water for ten minutes is a sufficient condition for killing him.

Check back soon!

Problem 2

Indicate whether the following principles are true or false and why.
1. If having feature $F$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $G$, then having feature $G$ is a necessary condition for having feature $F$.
2. If having feature $F$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $G$, then lacking feature $F$ is a necessary condition for lacking feature $G$.
3. If lacking feature $F$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $G$, then having feature $F$ is a necessary condition for lacking feature $G$.
4. If lacking feature $F$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $G$, then lacking feature $F$ is a necessary condition for having feature $G$.
5. If having either feature $F$ or feature $G$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $H$, then having feature $F$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $H$.
6. If having either feature $F$ or feature $G$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $H$, then having feature $G$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $H$.
7. If having either feature $F$ or feature $G$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $H$, then not having feature $F$ is a necessary condition for not having feature $H$.
8. If having both feature $F$ and feature $G$ is a necessary condition for having feature $H$, then lacking feature $F$ is a sufficient condition for lacking feature $H$.
9. If not having both feature $F$ and feature $G$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $H$, then lacking feature $F$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $H$.
10. If having either feature $F$ or feature $G$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $H$, then having both feature $F$ and feature $G$ is a sufficient condition for having feature $H$.

Check back soon!
01:23

Problem 3

For each of the following tables determine
a. Which, if any, of the candidates $-A, B, C$, or $D$-is not eliminated by the sufficient condition test as a sufficient condition for target feature $G$ ?
b. Which, if any, of the candidates $-A, B, C$, or $D$-is not eliminated by the necessary condition test as a necessary condition for target feature $G$ ?
c. Which, if any, of the candidates- $A, B, C$, or $D$-is not eliminated by either test?

James Kiss
James Kiss
Numerade Educator

Problem 4

Imagine that your desktop computer system won't work, and you want to find out why. After checking to make sure that it is plugged in, you experiment with a new central processing unit (CPU), a new monitor (MO), and new system software (SW) in the combinations on the table below. The candidates for necessary conditions and sufficient conditions of failure are the plug position (in or out), the CPU (old or new), the monitor (old or new), and the software (old or new). For each candidate, say (1) which cases, if any, eliminate it as a sufficient condition of your computer's failure and (2) which cases, if any, eliminate it as a necessary condition of your computer's failure. Which candidates, if any, are not eliminated as a sufficient condition of failure? As a necessary condition of failure? Does it follow that these candidates are necessary conditions or sufficient conditions of failure? Why or why not?
TABLE CAN'T COPY.

Check back soon!

Problem 5

After a banquet, several diners get sick and die. You suspect that something they ate or drank caused their deaths. The following table records their meals and fates. The target feature is death. The candidates for necessary conditions and sufficient conditions of death are the soup, entrée, wine, and dessert. For each candidate, say (1) which cases, if any, eliminate it as a sufficient condition of death and (2) which cases, if any, eliminate it as a necessary condition of death. Which candidates, if any, are not eliminated as a sufficient condition of death? Which candidates, if any, are not eliminated as a necessary condition of death? Does it follow that these candidates are necessary conditions or sufficient conditions of death? Why or why not?
TABLE CAN'T COPY.

Check back soon!
06:26

Problem 6

In each of the following examples a strong correlation, either negative or positive, holds between two sets of phenomena, $A$ and $B$. Try to decide whether $A$ is the cause of $B, B$ is the cause of $A$, both are caused by some third factor, $C$, or the correlation is simply accidental. Explain your choice.
1. For a particular United States president, there is a negative correlation between the number of hairs on his head $(A)$ and the population of China $(B)$.
2. My son's height (A) increases along with the height of the tree outside my front door (B).
3. It has been claimed that there is a strong positive correlation between those students who take sex education courses (A) and those who contract venereal disease (B).
4. At one time there was a strong negative correlation between the number of mules in a state (A) and the salaries paid to professors at the state university (B). In other words, the more mules, the lower professional salaries. ${ }^6$
5. There is a high positive correlation between the number of fire engines in a particular borough in New York City (A) and the number of fires that occur there (B). ${ }^7$
6. "Washington (UPI)-Rural Americans with locked doors, watchdogs or guns may face as much risk of burglary as neighbors who leave doors unlocked, a federally financed study says. The study, financed in part by a three-year $$\$ 170,000$$ grant from the Law Enforcement Assistance Administration, was based on a survey of nearly 900 families in rural Ohio. Sixty percent of the rural residents surveyed regularly locked doors $[A]$, but were burglarized more often than residents who left doors unlocked $[B] . .^{\prime \prime s}$
7. The speed of a car (A) is exactly the same as the speed of its shadow (B).
8. The length of a runner's ring finger minus the length of the runner's index finger $(\mathrm{A})$ is correlated with the runner's speed in the one-hundredyard dash (B).

Sherrie Fenner
Sherrie Fenner
Numerade Educator