• Home
  • Textbooks
  • Introducing advanced macroeconomics: growth and business cycles
  • Monetary policy and aggregate demand

Introducing advanced macroeconomics: growth and business cycles

Peter Birch Sørensen, Hans Jørgen Whitta-Jacobsen

Chapter 16

Monetary policy and aggregate demand - all with Video Answers

Educators


Chapter Questions

03:40

Problem 1

Topics in the theory of aggregate demand
1. Explain the concepts of the ex post real interest rate and the ex ante real interest rate. Which of these measures is most relevant as an indicator of the incentive to save and invest? Which of the two measures is most relevant for judging how inflation affects the distribution of income between borrowers and lenders? How are the two measurss of the real interest rate related to the popular measure $i_1-\pi_t$ ?
2. Why does the $\mathrm{AD}$ curve slope downwards? Which factors can cause the $A D$ curve to shift? Which factors determine the slope of the $\mathrm{AD}$ curve? In particular, explain in economic terms why a higher value of the parameter $b$ in the Taylor rule makes the AD curve steoper.

Arrushi Agarwal
Arrushi Agarwal
Numerade Educator

Problem 2

Interest rate setting under a constant money growth rule
When we derived the central bank's interest rate reaction function (20) under the constant money growth rule, we assumed for simplicity that there was no growth in trend output. We will now assume instead that trend output grows at the constant rate $x$ so that:
$$
\hat{Y}=(1+x) \tilde{Y}_{-1} \Rightarrow \hat{y}=\bar{y}_{-1}+x, \quad \hat{y}=\ln \hat{Y}_{,}, \hat{y}_{-1}=\ln \hat{Y}_{-1},
$$
where we have used the approximation $\ln (1+x)=x$. Following Section 16.3 and the notation used there, we specify the demand for real money balances as:
$$
L=k Y^v e^{-A} .
$$
1. Show by means of (35) and (36) that the growth rate of the demand for real money balances in a long-run equilibrium is approximately equal to $\eta x$. (Hint: approximate the growth rate in real money demand by $\ln L-\ln L_1$, Show that in long-run equilibrium, the rate of inflation will be given by $\pi=\mu-\eta x$, where $\mu$ is the constant growth rate of the nominal money supply, defined by $M=(1+\mu) M_{-1}$. (Hint: you may approximate the growth rate of the real money supply by $\ln (M / P)-\ln \left(M_{-1} / P_{-1}\right)$ using the fact that $\left.P=(1+\pi) P_{-1}\right)$
We now invite you to derive an equation showing how the central bank should set the short-term interest rate if it wishes to maintain a constant growth rate $\mu$ of the nominal money supply, in accordance with Milton Friedman's recommendation. You may assume that the economy is in long-run equilibrium in the previous period, with a nominal interest rate equal to $i_{-1}=f+\mu-\eta X$. Given that the money market clears in every period, we then have:
2. Use (35) and (37) to show that Friedman's constant money growth rule requires the central bank to set the nominal interest rate (approximately) in accordance with the rule:
$$
i=\tilde{t}+\pi+\left(\frac{\eta}{\beta}\right)(y-\hat{y}]+\left(\frac{1-\beta}{\beta}\right)[\pi-(\mu-\eta x)] .
$$
3. Friedman has argued that the interest sensitivity of money demand $(\beta)$ is very low (although positive). What does this imply for the evolution over time in the nominal and real interest rate if monetary policy makers follow the constant money growth rule? Do you see any problem in this?

Check back soon!

Problem 3

Nominal GDP targeting
In the main text of this chapter we discussed the constant money growth rule which is intended to ensure a stable evolution of aggregate nominal income. Given this goal, some economists have proposed that the central bank should not focus on the evolution of the nominal money supply as such but rather adopt a target growth rate for nominal GDP. Such a rule would allow real GDP to grow faster when inflation falls and would require real growth to be dampened when inflation rises. In formal terms, if the target growth rate of nominal GDP is $\mu$, the central bank must adjust the interest rate to ensure that:
numinal GDe grawh
$$
\overbrace{y-y_{-1}+\pi}=\mu_3
$$
where $y$ is the $\log$ of GDP so that $y-y_{-1}$ is the growth rate of real GDP. Ignoring fluctuations in confidence and government spending $(z=0)$, and assuming static inflation expectations so that the ex ante real interest rate becomes equal to $i-\pi$, we may write the goods market equilibrium condition as:
$$
y-\hat{y}=-\alpha_2(i-\pi-t) .
$$

Finally, suppose that trend output grows at the constant rate $x$ so that:
$$
\bar{y}=\hat{y}_{-1}+x .
$$
1. Derive the policy rule for interest rate setting under nominal GDP targeting. How does the interast rate react to inflation? How does it react to the lagged output gap $y_{-1}-\bar{y}_{-1}$ ? Explain in economic terms why and how the parameter $\alpha_2$ affects the central bank's interest rate response to changes in the rate of inflation and in the lagged output gap.
2. Compare interest rate setting under nominal GDP targeting to interest rate setting under the Taylor rule and under the constant money growth rule. Explain similarities and differences. Do you see any advantages of nominal GDP targeting compared to Friedman's constant money growth rule? Give reasons for your answer.

Check back soon!

Problem 4

Topics in monetary policy
1. Explain and discuss the arguments underlying the constant money growth rule for monetary policy. Explain the similarities and differences between the constent money growth rule and the Taylor rule. What could be the argument for choosing a Taylor rule rather than a constant money growth rule? Is it possible to determine by empirical analysis whether a central bank follows a constant monsy growth rule or a Taylor rule?
2. Explain the expectations hypothesis of the link between short-term interest rates and longterm interest rates. What is the crucial assumption underlying the expectations hypothesis? Is this assumption reasonable? Discuss the central bank's possibility of controlling long-term interest rates through its control of the short-term interest rate.
3. Discuss why financial market analysts study the official statements of central bankers so carefully and why central bankers seem to be so careful about what they say. Most observers argue that central banks should be as open and transparent about their analysis of the economic situation and their policy intentions as possible, but some argue that complete openness may not be the optimal policy. Try to think of arguments for and against maximum transparency of central banks. (As a source of inspiration, you may want to consult the article 'It's not always good to talk', The Economist, 24-30 July 2004, p. 65.)

Check back soon!

Problem 5

Embedding the yield curve and risk premia in the aggregate demand curve
The aggregate demand curve in Eq. (33a) assumes that long-term and short-term market interest rates always move in parallel and that the central bank always strictly follows the Taylor rule. This exercise invites you to analyse how the AD curve may be modified to account for the facts that long-term interest rates do not always move one-to-one with short-term interest rates and that the central bank does not always strictly adhere to a fixed monetary policy rule. We start by restating the term structure equation (25), where we drop the common time subscript $t$ for convenience:
$$
i^l=\frac{1}{n}\left(i+i_{41}^n+i_{42}^*+\ldots+i_{+m-1}^n\right)
$$

Now subtract the expected inflation rate $\pi_{+1}^e$ from both sides of (42) to get:
$$
\begin{aligned}
& r=\frac{1}{\mathrm{n}}\left(I^s+I_{+1}^\sigma+I_{+2}^m+\ldots+I_{+5-2}^\sigma\right), \\
& r=i^1-\pi_{* 1}^*, \quad r^k=i-\pi_{+1}^*, \quad r_{+j}^{n j}=i_{+j}^*=\pi_{+1}^* \quad \text { for } 1 \leq j \leq n-1 \\
&
\end{aligned}
$$

The variable $r$ is the curvent long-term real interest rate, $r^s$ is the current short-term real interest rate, and $r_{+j}^{s p}$ is the expected short-term real interest rate for the future period $t+j$ on the simplifying assumption that the inflation rate is expected to stay constant. To keep things simple, suppose that
$$
\begin{array}{ll}
r_{* j}^m=r^s & \text { for } 1 \leq j \leq m-1, \\
r_{+j}^{* f}=r & \text { for } m \leq j \leq n-1 .
\end{array}
$$

Thus we assume that the short-term real interest rate is expected to remain at its current level until period $m$, and that it will return to its long-run equilibrium level $f$ from that time onwards. The parameter $m$ indicates how quickly the market expects the economy to return to long-run equilibrium.
1. Suppose $\vec{r}>r^t$. Draw a diagram to illustrate the qualitative properties of the yield curve implied by (43) and (44).
2. Use equations (43) and (44) to show that
$$
r=\omega\left(1-\pi_{+1}^s\right)+(1-\omega) \tilde{r}, \quad \omega=\frac{m}{n} .
$$

In the following, $i^p$ denotes the official interest rate set by the central bank, while $i$ denotes the current short-term interest rate formed in the interbank market. We assume that
$$
\begin{aligned}
& \hat{i}=\hat{\rho}^\rho+\rho, \\
& i^\eta=\tilde{f}-\rho+\pi_{+1}^e+h\left(\pi-\pi^*\right)+b(y-\hat{y}]+d, \quad \bar{\rho}=E[\rho], E[d]=0 .
\end{aligned}
$$

The variable $\rho$ is a risk premium and $\rho$ is its long-run mean value, so $\bar{f}-\bar{\rho}$ is the risk-free equilibrium real interest rate introduced in Section 16.4. The random variable d captures so-called discretionary monetary policy, reflecting that central bankers do not rigidly and mechanically follow a fixed policy rule. However, by restricting the mean value of $d$ to be zero, we assume that 'on average', the central bank does adhere to the Taylor rule.
3. Use (45), (46), (47) plus (12) from the chapter text to derive an AD curve of the same general form as (33) and (34). Specify how the definitions of $\alpha$ and $\mathrm{z}$ in (34) change when we incorporate the yield curve, risk premia and discretionary policy in the AD curve.
4. Write down a complete list of the types of shocks that may shift the $\mathrm{AD}$ curve derived in Question 3. Explain how the emergence of a risk premium in the interbank market will affect the AD curve. Explain also how a discretionary loosening of monetary policy (that is, a central bank interest rate cut that is not warranted by the Taylor rule) will affect the $A D$ curve.

Check back soon!