The synthesis of cyclobutanecarboxylic acid given in Section 18.7 was first carried out by William Perkin, Jr., in 1883, and it represented one of the first syntheses of an organic compound with a ring smaller than six carbon atoms. (There was a general feeling at the time that such compounds would be too unstable to cxis.) Earlicr in $1883,$ Perkin reported what he mistakenly believed to be a cyclobutane derivative obtained from the reaction of accroaccitic ester and 1,3 -dibromopropane. The reaction that Perkin had expected to take place was the following:
CAN'T COPY THE FIGURE
The molecular formula for his product agreed with the formulation given in the preceding reaction, and alkaline hydrolysis and acidification gave a nicely crystalline acid (also having the expected molecular formula). The acid, however, was quite stable to heat and resisted decarboxylation. Perkin later found that both the ester and the acid contained six-membered rings (five carbon atoms and one oxygen atom). Recall the charge discribution in the enolate ion obtained from accroaccetic ester and propose structures for Perkin's ester and acid.