Question

Answer the five questions in the text about each of the following appeals to authority, and then decide whether each appeal to authority is legitimate or fallacious. 1. The surgeon general says that smoking is hazardous to your health, so it is. 2. The surgeon general says that abortion is immoral, so it is. 3. Michael Jordan says that Air Jordan sneakers are springier, so they must be springier. 4. This must be a great movie, because the billboard says that Time magazine called it "terrific." 5. My friend Joe says that this new movie is hilarious, so it must be worth watching. 6. Ben and Jerry's ice cream must be the best, because Fat Fred eats more ice cream than anyone else I know, and he says that Ben and Jerry's is the best. 7. There must be life on other planets, because many great scientists are looking for it, so they must think it is there. 8. Lefty Lopez must be the best pitcher of the year, because he won the Cy Young Award (awarded by the Baseball Writers Association to the best pitcher of the year). 9. Vanna must be the most beautiful woman in America, because she won the Miss America contest. 10. There were 250,000 protesters at the rally, because its organizers gave that figure. 11. There were 25,000 protesters at the rally, because its opponents said so. 12. True Christians ought to give away all their money, because the Bible says, "Blessed are the poor."

   Answer the five questions in the text about each of the following appeals to authority, and then decide whether each appeal to authority is legitimate or fallacious.
1. The surgeon general says that smoking is hazardous to your health, so it is.
2. The surgeon general says that abortion is immoral, so it is.
3. Michael Jordan says that Air Jordan sneakers are springier, so they must be springier.
4. This must be a great movie, because the billboard says that Time magazine called it "terrific."
5. My friend Joe says that this new movie is hilarious, so it must be worth watching.
6. Ben and Jerry's ice cream must be the best, because Fat Fred eats more ice cream than anyone else I know, and he says that Ben and Jerry's is the best.
7. There must be life on other planets, because many great scientists are looking for it, so they must think it is there.
8. Lefty Lopez must be the best pitcher of the year, because he won the Cy Young Award (awarded by the Baseball Writers Association to the best pitcher of the year).
9. Vanna must be the most beautiful woman in America, because she won the Miss America contest.
10. There were 250,000 protesters at the rally, because its organizers gave that figure.
11. There were 25,000 protesters at the rally, because its opponents said so.
12. True Christians ought to give away all their money, because the Bible says, "Blessed are the poor."
Show more…
Cengage Advantage Books: Understanding Arguments: An Introduction to Informal Logic
Cengage Advantage Books: Understanding Arguments: An Introduction to Informal Logic
Walter… 9th Edition
Chapter 15, Problem 3 ↓

Instant Answer

verified

Step 1

Step 2: Determine the credibility of the authority being cited. Step 3: Assess whether the authority's expertise is relevant to the claim being made. Step 4: Evaluate the context and potential biases of the authority. Step 5: Decide if the appeal to  Show more…

Show all steps

lock
AceChat toggle button
Close icon
Ace pointing down

Please give Ace some feedback

Your feedback will help us improve your experience

Thumb up icon Thumb down icon
Thanks for your feedback!
Profile picture
Answer the five questions in the text about each of the following appeals to authority, and then decide whether each appeal to authority is legitimate or fallacious. 1. The surgeon general says that smoking is hazardous to your health, so it is. 2. The surgeon general says that abortion is immoral, so it is. 3. Michael Jordan says that Air Jordan sneakers are springier, so they must be springier. 4. This must be a great movie, because the billboard says that Time magazine called it "terrific." 5. My friend Joe says that this new movie is hilarious, so it must be worth watching. 6. Ben and Jerry's ice cream must be the best, because Fat Fred eats more ice cream than anyone else I know, and he says that Ben and Jerry's is the best. 7. There must be life on other planets, because many great scientists are looking for it, so they must think it is there. 8. Lefty Lopez must be the best pitcher of the year, because he won the Cy Young Award (awarded by the Baseball Writers Association to the best pitcher of the year). 9. Vanna must be the most beautiful woman in America, because she won the Miss America contest. 10. There were 250,000 protesters at the rally, because its organizers gave that figure. 11. There were 25,000 protesters at the rally, because its opponents said so. 12. True Christians ought to give away all their money, because the Bible says, "Blessed are the poor."
Close icon
Play audio
Feedback
Powered by NumerAI
*

Labs

-

Want to see this concept in action?

NEW

Explore this concept interactively to see how it behaves as you change inputs.

View Labs

*

Key Concepts

-
Legitimate Authority
A legitimate appeal occurs when the cited authority has verifiable expertise and credible, relevant evidence about the topic. The authority’s opinion is considered valid because it is based on expertise or empirical research in the appropriate field.
Fallacious Appeal to Authority
This fallacy arises when the authority cited is not suitably qualified, not relevant to the topic, or when the argument depends solely on the authority’s endorsement without additional supporting evidence. It is important to distinguish between a credible expert opinion and an unsupported assertion from an unqualified source.
Evaluating Expert Testimony
This concept involves assessing whether an authority’s expertise, experience, and reliability justify using their opinion as the basis for a claim. A proper evaluation checks the relevance of the expert’s background to the specific issue and considers whether independent evidence supports the claim.
Appeal to Authority
This is an argument strategy where a claim is supported by citing someone perceived as an expert or authority. The strength of such an argument depends on whether the authority is genuinely credible in relation to the subject being discussed.

*

Recommended Videos

-
3which-of-the-following-are-moral-value-judgments-1-marinas-car-puts-out-horrible-smoke-for-the-sake-of-us-all-she-should-get-it-tuned-up-2-after-the-surgery-nickys-eyesight-improved-conside-27195

Which of the following are moral value judgments? 1. Marina's car puts out horrible smoke; for the sake of us all, she should get it tuned up. 2. After the surgery, Nicky's eyesight improved considerably. 3. Ms. Beeson ought not to have embezzled money from the bank. 4. Violence is always wrong. 5. Matthew ought to wear that sweater more often; it looks great on him. 6. Sandy, you are one of the laziest people I know! 7. My computer software is really good; it even corrects my grammar. 8. Lisa has been very good tonight, according to the babysitter. 9. Judge Ramesh is quite well-informed. 10. Judge Ramesh's decision gave each party exactly what it deserved. 11. The editor couldn't use my illustrations; she said they were not particularly interesting. 12. Wow. That was a tasty meal! 13. The last set of essays was much better than the first set. 14. Do unto others as you would have them do unto you. 15. People who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones. 16. You really shouldn't make so much noise when the people upstairs are trying to sleep. 17. It is unfair the way Professor Smith asks questions no normal person can answer. 18. "Allegro" means fast, but not that fast! 19. Being in touch with God gives your life meaning and value. 20. Thou shalt not kill.

Need help? Use Ace
Ace is your personal tutor. It breaks down any question with clear steps so you can learn.
Start Using Ace
Ace is your personal tutor for learning
Step-by-step explanations
Instant summaries
Summarize YouTube videos
Understand textbook images or PDFs
Study tools like quizzes and flashcards
Listen to your notes as a podcast
Continue solving this problem
Create a free account to:
  • View full step-by-step solution
  • Ask follow-up questions with Ace AI
  • Save progress and study later
Continue Free
Numerade

Get step-by-step video solution
from top educators

Continue with Clever
or



By creating an account, you agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Already have an account? Log In

A free answer
just for you

Watch the video solution with this free unlock.

Numerade

Log in to watch this video
...and 100,000,000 more!


EMAIL

PASSWORD

OR
Continue with Clever