Question

For each of the following arguments, does it involve circular reasoning? Does it beg the question in any context? If so, in which contexts? Explain your answers. 1. A student of mine told me that I am her favorite professor, and I know that she is telling the truth, because no student would lie to her favorite professor. 2. Intoxicating beverages should be banned, because they can make people drunk. 3. Capitalism is the only correct economic system, because without it free enterprise would be impossible. 4. Free trade is good for the country, because it brings the country all of the advantages of an unimpeded flow of goods. 5. Gun-control laws are wrong, because they violate the citizen's right to bear arms. 6. When $B$ applies for a job from $A$ : A: How can we know that you are trustworthy? B: Mr. Davidson will write me a recommendation. A: But why should we trust him? B: I assure you that he is honest and accurate. 7. The Bible is the inerrant word of God, because God speaks only the truth, and repeatedly in the Bible God tells us that the Bible consists of His words. 8. We have to accept change, because without change there is no progress. 9. Premarital sex is wrong, because premarital sex is fornication, and fornication is a sin. 10. The drinking age should be lowered to eighteen, because eighteen-yearolds are mature enough to drink. 11. We should never give security clearances to homosexuals, because they can be blackmailed into revealing classified information. They are subject to blackmail, because we will revoke their security clearances if we find out they are gay. 12. People with suicidal tendencies are insane, because they want to kill themselves. 13. Jeffrey can't really be insane, because he says he is.

   For each of the following arguments, does it involve circular reasoning? Does it beg the question in any context? If so, in which contexts? Explain your answers.
1. A student of mine told me that I am her favorite professor, and I know that she is telling the truth, because no student would lie to her favorite professor.
2. Intoxicating beverages should be banned, because they can make people drunk.
3. Capitalism is the only correct economic system, because without it free enterprise would be impossible.
4. Free trade is good for the country, because it brings the country all of the advantages of an unimpeded flow of goods.
5. Gun-control laws are wrong, because they violate the citizen's right to bear arms.
6. When $B$ applies for a job from $A$ :
A: How can we know that you are trustworthy?
B: Mr. Davidson will write me a recommendation.
A: But why should we trust him?
B: I assure you that he is honest and accurate.
7. The Bible is the inerrant word of God, because God speaks only the truth, and repeatedly in the Bible God tells us that the Bible consists of His words.
8. We have to accept change, because without change there is no progress.
9. Premarital sex is wrong, because premarital sex is fornication, and fornication is a sin.
10. The drinking age should be lowered to eighteen, because eighteen-yearolds are mature enough to drink.
11. We should never give security clearances to homosexuals, because they can be blackmailed into revealing classified information. They are subject to blackmail, because we will revoke their security clearances if we find out they are gay.
12. People with suicidal tendencies are insane, because they want to kill themselves.
13. Jeffrey can't really be insane, because he says he is.
Show more…
Cengage Advantage Books: Understanding Arguments: An Introduction to Informal Logic
Cengage Advantage Books: Understanding Arguments: An Introduction to Informal Logic
Walter… 9th Edition
Chapter 16, Problem 1 ↓

Instant Answer

verified

Step 1

" - This argument involves circular reasoning because it assumes that students do not lie to their favorite professors without providing evidence for that claim. It begs the question in contexts where the trustworthiness of the student’s statement is in doubt.  Show more…

Show all steps

lock
AceChat toggle button
Close icon
Ace pointing down

Please give Ace some feedback

Your feedback will help us improve your experience

Thumb up icon Thumb down icon
Thanks for your feedback!
Profile picture
For each of the following arguments, does it involve circular reasoning? Does it beg the question in any context? If so, in which contexts? Explain your answers. 1. A student of mine told me that I am her favorite professor, and I know that she is telling the truth, because no student would lie to her favorite professor. 2. Intoxicating beverages should be banned, because they can make people drunk. 3. Capitalism is the only correct economic system, because without it free enterprise would be impossible. 4. Free trade is good for the country, because it brings the country all of the advantages of an unimpeded flow of goods. 5. Gun-control laws are wrong, because they violate the citizen's right to bear arms. 6. When $B$ applies for a job from $A$ : A: How can we know that you are trustworthy? B: Mr. Davidson will write me a recommendation. A: But why should we trust him? B: I assure you that he is honest and accurate. 7. The Bible is the inerrant word of God, because God speaks only the truth, and repeatedly in the Bible God tells us that the Bible consists of His words. 8. We have to accept change, because without change there is no progress. 9. Premarital sex is wrong, because premarital sex is fornication, and fornication is a sin. 10. The drinking age should be lowered to eighteen, because eighteen-yearolds are mature enough to drink. 11. We should never give security clearances to homosexuals, because they can be blackmailed into revealing classified information. They are subject to blackmail, because we will revoke their security clearances if we find out they are gay. 12. People with suicidal tendencies are insane, because they want to kill themselves. 13. Jeffrey can't really be insane, because he says he is.
Close icon
Play audio
Feedback
Powered by NumerAI
Need help? Use Ace
Ace is your personal tutor. It breaks down any question with clear steps so you can learn.
Start Using Ace
Ace is your personal tutor for learning
Step-by-step explanations
Instant summaries
Summarize YouTube videos
Understand textbook images or PDFs
Study tools like quizzes and flashcards
Listen to your notes as a podcast
Continue solving this problem
Create a free account to:
  • View full step-by-step solution
  • Ask follow-up questions with Ace AI
  • Save progress and study later
Continue Free
Numerade

Get step-by-step video solution
from top educators

Continue with Clever
or



By creating an account, you agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Already have an account? Log In

A free answer
just for you

Watch the video solution with this free unlock.

Numerade

Log in to watch this video
...and 100,000,000 more!


EMAIL

PASSWORD

OR
Continue with Clever