Question

For each of the following explanations, specify which standard of a good explanation, if any, it violates. The standards require that a good explanation be explanatory, deep, powerful, falsifiable, modest, simple, and conservative. A single explanation might violate more than one standard. 1. Although we usually have class at this time in this room, I don't see anybody in the classroom, because a wicked witch made them all invisible. 2. Although we usually have class at this time in this room, I don't see anybody in the classroom, because they all decided to skip class today. 3. Although we usually have class at this time in this room, I don't see anybody in the classroom, because it's Columbus Day. 4. My house fell down, because it was painted red. 5. My house fell down, because of a powerful earthquake centered on my property that did not affect anything or anybody else. 6. My house fell down, because its boards were struck by a new kind of subatomic particle. 7. Although I fished here all day, I didn't catch any fish, because there are no fish in this whole river. 8. Although I fished here all day, I didn't catch any fish, because the river gods don't like me. 9. Although I fished here all day, I didn't catch any fish, because I was unlucky today. 10. That light far up in the night sky is moving quickly, because it is the daily United Airlines flight from Boston to Los Angeles. 11. That light far up in the night sky is moving quickly, because it is an alien space ship. 12. That light far up in the night sky looks like it is moving quickly, because there's something wrong with my eyes right now.

   For each of the following explanations, specify which standard of a good explanation, if any, it violates. The standards require that a good explanation be explanatory, deep, powerful, falsifiable, modest, simple, and conservative. A single explanation might violate more than one standard.
1. Although we usually have class at this time in this room, I don't see anybody in the classroom, because a wicked witch made them all invisible.
2. Although we usually have class at this time in this room, I don't see anybody in the classroom, because they all decided to skip class today.
3. Although we usually have class at this time in this room, I don't see anybody in the classroom, because it's Columbus Day.
4. My house fell down, because it was painted red.
5. My house fell down, because of a powerful earthquake centered on my property that did not affect anything or anybody else.
6. My house fell down, because its boards were struck by a new kind of subatomic particle.
7. Although I fished here all day, I didn't catch any fish, because there are no fish in this whole river.
8. Although I fished here all day, I didn't catch any fish, because the river gods don't like me.
9. Although I fished here all day, I didn't catch any fish, because I was unlucky today.
10. That light far up in the night sky is moving quickly, because it is the daily United Airlines flight from Boston to Los Angeles.
11. That light far up in the night sky is moving quickly, because it is an alien space ship.
12. That light far up in the night sky looks like it is moving quickly, because there's something wrong with my eyes right now.

Show more…
Cengage Advantage Books: Understanding Arguments: An Introduction to Informal Logic
Cengage Advantage Books: Understanding Arguments: An Introduction to Informal Logic
Walter… 9th Edition
Chapter 9, Problem 2 ↓

Instant Answer

verified

Step 1

" - Violates: Explanatory (the explanation is fantastical and lacks a basis in reality), Falsifiable (it cannot be tested or disproven), and Modest (it makes an extraordinary claim without sufficient evidence).  Show more…

Show all steps

lock
AceChat toggle button
Close icon
Ace pointing down

Please give Ace some feedback

Your feedback will help us improve your experience

Thumb up icon Thumb down icon
Thanks for your feedback!
Profile picture
For each of the following explanations, specify which standard of a good explanation, if any, it violates. The standards require that a good explanation be explanatory, deep, powerful, falsifiable, modest, simple, and conservative. A single explanation might violate more than one standard. 1. Although we usually have class at this time in this room, I don't see anybody in the classroom, because a wicked witch made them all invisible. 2. Although we usually have class at this time in this room, I don't see anybody in the classroom, because they all decided to skip class today. 3. Although we usually have class at this time in this room, I don't see anybody in the classroom, because it's Columbus Day. 4. My house fell down, because it was painted red. 5. My house fell down, because of a powerful earthquake centered on my property that did not affect anything or anybody else. 6. My house fell down, because its boards were struck by a new kind of subatomic particle. 7. Although I fished here all day, I didn't catch any fish, because there are no fish in this whole river. 8. Although I fished here all day, I didn't catch any fish, because the river gods don't like me. 9. Although I fished here all day, I didn't catch any fish, because I was unlucky today. 10. That light far up in the night sky is moving quickly, because it is the daily United Airlines flight from Boston to Los Angeles. 11. That light far up in the night sky is moving quickly, because it is an alien space ship. 12. That light far up in the night sky looks like it is moving quickly, because there's something wrong with my eyes right now.
Close icon
Play audio
Feedback
Powered by NumerAI
*

Labs

-

Want to see this concept in action?

NEW

Explore this concept interactively to see how it behaves as you change inputs.

View Labs

*

Key Concepts

-
Simple
Simplicity is valued in explanations when they avoid unnecessary complexity and do not include superfluous assumptions. A simple explanation achieves clarity by focusing on the essential elements needed to account for the phenomenon, following the principle of parsimony or Occam's Razor.
Powerful
A powerful explanation is one that is capable of explaining a wide range of phenomena with minimal assumptions. It unifies disparate observations under a single framework, showing a high degree of generality and the ability to predict future events or observations.
Conservative
A conservative explanation aligns closely with established knowledge and accepted theories, incorporating new data without radically departing from what is already well-supported. This approach minimizes the introduction of untested or extreme hypotheses and maintains continuity with existing understanding.
Modest
Modesty in an explanation entails refraining from making claims that exceed what the evidence can support. A modest explanation avoids excessive speculation and adheres closely to what is warranted by the available data, reducing the risk of overgeneralization.
Deep
Depth in an explanation means that it goes beyond superficial descriptions and addresses the underlying structures or mechanisms that produce the outcome. A deep explanation reveals the intricacies of how things work, uncovering layers of causality that may not be immediately obvious.
Explanatory
This concept refers to the quality of an explanation in which it provides clear, relevant, and sufficient reasons for a phenomenon. An explanatory explanation connects observations or events to underlying causes in a logically coherent way, ensuring that the listener or reader can understand why the phenomenon occurred.
Falsifiable
Falsifiability is the characteristic of an explanation that allows it to be proven wrong if it is indeed incorrect. For an explanation to be scientifically robust, it must make predictions or claims that can be tested and potentially refuted through empirical evidence.

*

Recommended Videos

-
exercise-3-which-of-the-following-is-an-explanation-and-which-is-an-argument-identify-the-main-conclusion-of-each-argument-or-explanation-remember-if-the-premises-seems-to-be-establishing-th-60395

Exercise 3: Which of the following is an explanation and which is an argument? Identify the main conclusion of each argument or explanation. (Remember if the premise(s) seem to be establishing that the conclusion is true, it is an argument, but if the premise(s) seem to be establishing why the conclusion is true, it is an explanation.) 1. Wanda rode the bus today because her car was in the shop. 2. Since Wanda doesn't have enough money in her bank account, she has not yet picked up her car from the shop. 3. Either Bob or Henry rode the bus to work today. But it wasn't Henry because I saw him riding his bike to work. Therefore, it was Bob. 4. It can't be snowing right now since it only snows when it is 32 degrees or below and right now it is 40 degrees. 5. The reason some people with schizophrenia hear voices in their head is that the cognitive mechanism that monitors their own self-talk is malfunctioning and they attribute their own self-talk to some external source. 6. Fracking should be allowed because, although it does involve some environmental risk, it reduces our dependence on foreign oil and there is much greater harm to the environment due to foreign oil drilling than there is due to fracking. 7. Wanda could not have ridden the bus today because today is a city-wide holiday and the bus service is not operating. 8. The Tigers lost their star pitcher due to injury over the weekend, therefore the Tigers will not win their game against the Pirates. 9. No one living in Pompeii could have escaped before the lava from Mt. Vesuvius hit. The reason is simple: the lava was flowing too fast and there was nowhere to go to escape it in time.

identify-which-explanatory-virtues-if-any-the-following-explanations-lack-and-explain-why-it-lacks-that-particular-virtue-if-there-is-a-better-explanation-suggest-what-it-might-be-1-bob-expl-25533

Identify which explanatory virtues, if any, the following explanations lack and explain why it lacks that particular virtue. If there is a better explanation, suggest what it might be. 1. Bob explains the fact that he can't remember what happened yesterday by saying that he must have been kidnapped by aliens, who performed surgery on him and then erased his memory of everything that happened the day before returning him to his house. 2. Mrs. Jones hears strange noises at night such as the creaking of the floor downstairs and rattling of windows. She explains these phenomena by hypothesizing that there is a 37-pound badger that inhabits the house and that emerges at night in search of Wheat Thins and Oreos.

the-seven-explanatory-virtues-are-explanatoriness-depth-power-falsifiability-modesty-simplicity-conservativeness-exercise-23-identify-which-explanatory-virtues-if-any-the-following-explanati-91955

The seven explanatory virtues are Explanatoriness, Depth, Power, Falsifiability, Modesty, Simplicity, Conservativeness. Exercise 23: Identify which explanatory virtues, if any, the following explanations lack and explain why it lacks that particular virtue. If there is a better explanation, suggest what it might be. Bob explains the fact that he can't remember what happened yesterday by saying that he must have been kidnapped by aliens, who performed surgery on him and then erased his memory of everything that happened the day before returning him to his house. Mrs. Jones hears strange noises at night such as the creaking of the floor downstairs and rattling of windows. She explains these phenomena by hypothesizing that there is a 37-pound badger that inhabits the house and that emerges at night in search of Wheat Thins and Oreos. Edward saw his friend Tom at the store in their hometown of Lincoln, Nebraska just an hour ago. Then, while watching the World Cup on television, he saw someone that looked just like Tom in the crowd at the game in Brazil. He hypothesizes that his friend Tom must have an identical twin that Tom has never told him about. Edward's friend Tom died two years ago. But just yesterday Tom saw someone who looked and spoke exactly like Tom. Edward hypothesizes that Tom must have come back to life. Edward's friend Tom died twenty years ago when Tom was just 18. But just yesterday Edward saw someone who looked and spoke exactly like Tom. Edward hypothesizes that Tom must have had a son that he did not know about and that this person must have been Tom's son.

Need help? Use Ace
Ace is your personal tutor. It breaks down any question with clear steps so you can learn.
Start Using Ace
Ace is your personal tutor for learning
Step-by-step explanations
Instant summaries
Summarize YouTube videos
Understand textbook images or PDFs
Study tools like quizzes and flashcards
Listen to your notes as a podcast
Continue solving this problem
Create a free account to:
  • View full step-by-step solution
  • Ask follow-up questions with Ace AI
  • Save progress and study later
Continue Free
Numerade

Get step-by-step video solution
from top educators

Continue with Clever
or



By creating an account, you agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Already have an account? Log In

A free answer
just for you

Watch the video solution with this free unlock.

Numerade

Log in to watch this video
...and 100,000,000 more!


EMAIL

PASSWORD

OR
Continue with Clever