Many particle accelerators, including the cyclotron and the synchrotron (Sections $17.11$ and $18.11$ ), hold charged particles in a circular orbit using a suitable magnetic field. The centripetal acceleration, $a=v^{2} / r$ can be very large and can lead to serious energy loss by radiation, in accordance with Eq. (11.1). (a) Consider a $10-\mathrm{MeV}$ proton in a cyclotron of radius $0.5 \mathrm{~m}$. Use the formula (11.1) to calculate the rate of energy loss in $\mathrm{eV} / \mathrm{s}$ due to radiation. (b) Suppose that we tried to produce electrons with the same kinetic energy in a circular machine of the same radius. In this case the motion would be relativistic and formula (11.1) is modified by an extra factor ${ }^{\text {* }}$ of $\gamma^{4}$ :
$$
P=\frac{2 k q^{2} a^{2} \gamma^{4}}{3 c^{3}}
$$
Find the rate of energy loss of the electron, and compare with that for a proton. (Your answer for the electron should be enormously larger than for the proton. This explains why most electron accelerators are linear, not circular, since the acceleration in a linear accelerator - once $v \sim c-$ is far smaller than the centripetal acceleration considered here.)