Question

You have a patient who has recently been diagnosed with myeloma and he is discussing treatment options with you. You are the full-time employee of an outpatient facility run by a managed-care plan and you have recently received written instructions not to bring up subjects such as bone marrow transplantation in myeloma with patients. The reasoning was that they are outrageously expensive and do not cure the disease, although it may extend survival. The data that they extend survival are not entirely conclusive. In addition, in a private meeting with the medical director, you have been told that the expenditures per patient load of care of each of the physicians would be examined yearly to determine which physician would be promoted. What do you do? a. Fully inform the patient about the risks and benefits of bone marrow transplantation. b. Refer your patient to an oncologist to have this discussion. c. Transfer the patient to another primary-care provider. d. Advise the patient to file suit against the managed care plan. e. Give the patient treatment with melphalan or thalidomide. f. Inform the patient about bone marrow transplantation if he asks you about it.

   You have a patient who has recently been diagnosed with myeloma and he is discussing treatment options with you. You are the full-time employee of an outpatient facility run by a managed-care plan and you have recently received written instructions not to bring up subjects such as bone marrow transplantation in myeloma with patients. The reasoning was that they are outrageously expensive and do not cure the disease, although it may extend survival. The data that they extend survival are not entirely conclusive. In addition, in a private meeting with the medical director, you have been told that the expenditures per patient load of care of each of the physicians would be examined yearly to determine which physician would be promoted.
What do you do?
a. Fully inform the patient about the risks and benefits of bone marrow transplantation.
b. Refer your patient to an oncologist to have this discussion.
c. Transfer the patient to another primary-care provider.
d. Advise the patient to file suit against the managed care plan.
e. Give the patient treatment with melphalan or thalidomide.
f. Inform the patient about bone marrow transplantation if he asks you about it.
Show more…
Medical Ethics for the Boards
Medical Ethics for the Boards
Conrad Fischer 3rd Edition
Chapter 1, Problem 71 ↓

Instant Answer

verified

Step 1

Step 1: Assess the ethical obligations and guidelines provided by the managed-care plan regarding patient communication about treatment options, particularly bone marrow transplantation.  Show more…

Show all steps

lock
AceChat toggle button
Close icon
Ace pointing down

Please give Ace some feedback

Your feedback will help us improve your experience

Thumb up icon Thumb down icon
Thanks for your feedback!
Profile picture
You have a patient who has recently been diagnosed with myeloma and he is discussing treatment options with you. You are the full-time employee of an outpatient facility run by a managed-care plan and you have recently received written instructions not to bring up subjects such as bone marrow transplantation in myeloma with patients. The reasoning was that they are outrageously expensive and do not cure the disease, although it may extend survival. The data that they extend survival are not entirely conclusive. In addition, in a private meeting with the medical director, you have been told that the expenditures per patient load of care of each of the physicians would be examined yearly to determine which physician would be promoted. What do you do? a. Fully inform the patient about the risks and benefits of bone marrow transplantation. b. Refer your patient to an oncologist to have this discussion. c. Transfer the patient to another primary-care provider. d. Advise the patient to file suit against the managed care plan. e. Give the patient treatment with melphalan or thalidomide. f. Inform the patient about bone marrow transplantation if he asks you about it.
Close icon
Play audio
Feedback
Powered by NumerAI
*

Labs

-

Want to see this concept in action?

NEW

Explore this concept interactively to see how it behaves as you change inputs.

View Labs

*

Key Concepts

-
Patient Autonomy and Informed Consent
Patient autonomy is the ethical principle that supports a patient’s right to receive comprehensive information about all of their treatment options and to participate in decision-making processes regarding their own care. Informed consent is closely related, requiring that patients receive clear, unbiased, and complete details about the risks, benefits, and alternatives of treatments so they can make decisions that align with their values and preferences.
Professional Integrity and Ethical Obligation
Healthcare professionals have a duty to act in the best interest of their patients, which includes providing honest and accurate information about treatment options regardless of external pressures. This ethical obligation requires clinicians to uphold truthfulness and transparency even when faced with administrative restrictions or financial incentives that might conflict with the interests of the patient.
Conflict of Interest in Healthcare
Conflicts of interest occur when financial, administrative, or personal considerations may interfere with a clinician's ability to recommend treatments in an unbiased manner. Recognizing and managing these conflicts is crucial to ensure that decisions are based on the best available evidence and the patient’s welfare, rather than on influences that could compromise the integrity of medical advice.

*

Recommended Videos

-
a-60-year-old-man-comes-to-the-physician-with-his-daughter-because-of-an-enlarging-mass-on-his-back-for-6-months-his-daughter-speaks-to-the-physician-privately-and-states-that-her-father-has-been-depr

A 60-year-old man comes to the physician with his daughter because of an enlarging mass on his back for 6 months. His daughter speaks to the physician privately and states that her father has been depressed since her mother died 1 year ago. She asks the physician not to tell her father if he has cancer because she is afraid he would kill himself. The patient lives alone and competently manages his affairs. Physical examination shows a 6-cm solid mass on the back. A biopsy specimen of the mass shows malignant cells. In addition to evaluating the patient's depression and risk for suicide, it is most appropriate for the physician to initially do which of the following? A) Arrange for a mental health professional to inform the patient of the diagnosis B) Ask the patient if he would like to know the diagnosis C) Consult with the hospital ethics committee about honoring the daughter's wishes D) Honor the daughter's request E) Inform the patient of the diagnosis

the-benefits-and-harms-of-high-risk-chemotherapy-taken-from-veatch-et-al-2015-case-studies-in-biomedical-ethics-oxford-university-press-pages-72-73-joe-cavanaugh-a-58-year-old-professor-of-e-99392

The Benefits and Harms of High-Risk Chemotherapy [Taken from Veatch, et. al. 2015. Case Studies in Biomedical Ethics. Oxford University Press, pages 72-73.] Joe Cavanaugh, a 58-year-old professor of economics, was diagnosed with chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML) several months ago. Though this particular type of leukemia is somewhat less responsive to chemotherapy, Dr. Cavanaugh responded well to a course of chemotherapy that he took orally shortly after his diagnosis. Dr. Cavanaugh's last blood count indicated that his white blood count was greatly reduced. During the course of his chemotherapy, Dr. Cavanaugh had become close to Heather Eyberg, Pharm.D., the clinical pharmacist in the cancer treatment center. After a follow-up visit with the oncologist, Dr. Cavanaugh stopped by Dr. Eyberg's office. Dr. Cavanaugh said, "The doctor has suggested several possibilities regarding my treatment. I trust you, and I would appreciate your opinion on my options. The doctor said that now that I have finished taking the oral chemotherapy, I could start interferon alpha or, if I want to be "cured," I should think about a stem cell transplant. The type of leukemia I have can rapidly change from this chronic phase into acute leukemia. If that happens, it is unlikely that anything would help, and I would not have long to live. The doctor wants me to think about a stem cell transplant. He said I could remain in this holding pattern for years, but there is no way of knowing. Or I could have high-dose chemotherapy and stem cell transplant. What do you think?" Dr. Eyberg respects Dr. Cavanaugh and his capacity to understand the risks and benefits involved in stem cell transplantation. She knows that allogenic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) is the only therapy proven to cure CML. If Dr. Cavanaugh has a sibling that is a match and has the HSCT within the first year of his diagnosis, he has a better five-year survival rate than those who undergo HSCT after the first year of diagnosis. So time is of the essence. The two options presented to Dr. Cavanaugh are essentially: watch, wait, take the interferon alpha and hope that the disease never progresses or take a chance on HSCT now. The risks of HSCT are substantial. The possibility of infection and other complications is very high. Since Dr. Eyberg is part of the cancer treatment team, she is unsure of where her moral commitment should lie. Should she counsel Dr. Cavanaugh to choose the least harmful course of therapy? The conservative route would probably be to watch and wait and take the interferon alpha. Yet, if the disease progresses to acute leukemia, there is little anyone could do to help Dr. Cavanaugh. However, Dr. Cavanaugh could be in the percentage of patients who never progress to this fatal phase of the disease. Even if he eventually did change to the fatal phase, Dr. Cavanaugh might have many good years with his wife and children until then. Dr. Eyberg could also counsel Dr. Cavanaugh to choose that option that maximizes the benefit for him. It is hard in this situation to determine which course of action will do the most good in the long run. Clearly, HSCT holds greater risk in the short run but offers the potential for a cure of Dr. Cavanaugh's leukemia in the long run. Finally, Dr. Eyberg is troubled by the memory of another patient with a similar diagnosis who recently chose the option of HSCT and did not survive the procedure. Given all of these considerations, Dr. Eyberg is not sure where to begin. Question: How would you counsel Dr. Cavanaugh? Use the principle of beneficence and/or nonmaleficence to support your response. Make sure you cite from the reading in your response.

which-of-the-following-is-part-of-a-physicians-responsibilities-to-a-patient-who-is-capable-of-discernment-please-choose-an-answer-a-refrain-from-having-an-opinion-on-a-therapeutic-choice-because-it-i

Which of the following is part of a physician's responsibilities to a patient who is capable of discernment? Please choose an answer: A. Refrain from having an opinion on a therapeutic choice, because it is up to the patient to decide. B. Counsel the patient until he chooses the medically indicated treatment. C. Collect as much information as possible from loved ones, in order to be able to make the right choice for the patient. D. Listen carefully to the patient, to better convince him. E. Help the patient understand his or her own priorities.

Need help? Use Ace
Ace is your personal tutor. It breaks down any question with clear steps so you can learn.
Start Using Ace
Ace is your personal tutor for learning
Step-by-step explanations
Instant summaries
Summarize YouTube videos
Understand textbook images or PDFs
Study tools like quizzes and flashcards
Listen to your notes as a podcast
Continue solving this problem
Create a free account to:
  • View full step-by-step solution
  • Ask follow-up questions with Ace AI
  • Save progress and study later
Continue Free
Numerade

Get step-by-step video solution
from top educators

Continue with Clever
or



By creating an account, you agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Already have an account? Log In

A free answer
just for you

Watch the video solution with this free unlock.

Numerade

Log in to watch this video
...and 100,000,000 more!


EMAIL

PASSWORD

OR
Continue with Clever