For the circuit shown in Fig. 29-2, find $I_{1}, I_{2}$, and $I_{3}$ if switch $S$ is $(a)$ open and $(b)$ closed.
(a) When $S$ is open, $I_{3}=0$, because no current can flow through the middle branch. Applying the node rule to point $-a$
$$
I_{1}+I_{3}=I_{2} \quad \text { or } \quad I_{2}=I_{1}+0=I_{1}
$$
Applying the loop rule to the outer loop acbda yields
$$
-12.0+7.0 I_{1}+8.0 I_{2}+9.0=0
$$
To understand the use of signs, remember that current always flows from high to low potential through
a resistor.
Because $I_{2}=I_{1}$, Eq. (1) becomes
$$
\begin{array}{lll}
15.0 I_{1}=3.0 & \text { or } & I_{1}=0.20 \mathrm{~A}
\end{array}
$$
Also, $I_{2}=I_{1}=0.20 \mathrm{~A}$. Notice that this is the same result that one would obtain by replacing the two batteries by a single $3.0$ - $\mathrm{V}$ battery.
(b) With $S$ closed, $I_{3}$ is no longer necessarily zero. Applying the node rule to point- $a$ gives
$$
I_{1}+I_{3}=I_{2}
$$
Applying the loop rule to loop acba
$$
-12.0+7.01 I_{1}-4.0 I_{3}=0
$$
and to loop adba gives
$$
-9.0-8.0 I_{2}-4.0 I_{3}=0
$$
Applying the loop rule to the remaining loop, acbda, would yield a redundant equation, because it would contain no new voltage change.
Now solve Eqs. (2), (3), and (4) for $I_{1}, I_{2}$, and $I_{3}$. From Eq. (4),
$$
I_{3}=-2.0 I_{2}-2.25
$$
Substituting this in Eq. (3) yields
$$
-12.0+7.0 I_{1}+9.0+8.0 I_{2}=0 \quad \text { or } \quad 7.0 I_{1}+8.0 I_{2}=3.0
$$
Substituting for $I_{3}$ in Eq. (2) also gives
$$
\begin{array}{lll}
I_{1}-2.0 I_{2}-2.25-I_{2} & \text { or } & I_{1}=3.0 I_{2}+2.25
\end{array}
$$
Substituting this value in the previous equation finally leads to
$$
21.0 I_{2}+15.75+8.0 I_{2}=3.0 \quad \text { or } \quad I_{2}=-0.44 \mathrm{~A}
$$
Using this in the equation for $I_{1}$,
$$
I_{1}=3.0(-0.44)+2.25=-1.32+2.25=0.93 \mathrm{~A}
$$
Notice that the minus sign is a part of the value we have found for $I_{2}$. It must be carried along with its numerical value. Now use (2) to find
$$
I_{3}=I_{2}-I_{1}=(-0.44)-0.93=-1.37 \mathrm{~A}
$$